Worksheets after school. A coaching college on Saturdays. An online tutor for homework. A maths app on the iPad. Most parents end up comparing a handful of very different kinds of help, and each one promises to make a difference.
Every one of them is good at something. The question is what it is good at, and what your child also needs. Our five bands give you a simple way to see that.
The five bands in one minute
Every child has a core learning level in each topic, and it isn’t the same as their age or year level. A Year 5 child might be working at Year 5 in fractions, Year 3 in measurement and Year 7 in geometry, all at the same time.
From that core learning level, learning climbs five steps:
- Earth (two year levels below): rebuild the foundations the new idea rests on.
- Water (one year level below): a tutor explicitly teaches the new idea through worked examples.
- Fire (core learning level): your child practises on their own for the first time.
- Air (one year level ahead): problem solving and challenge that connect ideas.
- Aether (two year levels ahead): homework and next week’s quiz check the rung is secure before moving on.
Between classes, the Learner’s Journey keeps learning going at home.
Which band does each kind of help cover?
Here is how the most common kinds of learning support line up. Coloured steps are what that kind of help is built around. Striped steps happen for some children, some of the time.
Daily worksheet programs
Built around short daily worksheets that repeat a skill until it’s quick and automatic, then a check before moving to the next level. Strong for revisiting the basics and building fluency.
They go from Earth to Fire to Aether and skip the steps in between: little explicit teaching of the new idea (Water), and little problem solving that connects ideas (Air).
This kind of help
Spectrum Tuition
Coaching colleges and practice-test programs
Built around exam-style questions and timed trial tests. Strong for stretch, exam technique and getting used to the pressure of the day.
Practice exams are Air: they stretch, but they don’t check that each rung is secure before moving on (Aether). And when a child has a gap further down (Earth), another practice test shows the gap but doesn’t rebuild it.
This kind of help
Spectrum Tuition
One-to-one online tutoring and homework help
Built around explaining the topic your child is stuck on this week. Strong for clear explanation, one step at a time, with full attention.
Sessions usually follow this week’s school topic, so earlier gaps (Earth) and planned extension (Air) depend on the tutor.
This kind of help
Spectrum Tuition
Maths apps and learning websites
Built around lots of practice questions with instant feedback, often set at year level. Strong for extra practice at home and keeping skills ticking over.
An app can mark an answer wrong, but it can’t easily see why, or teach the missing step underneath (Earth and Water).
This kind of help
Spectrum Tuition
School
Built to teach the year-level curriculum to a whole class at once. Strong for breadth, friendships and everything a school day gives a child.
Extension (Air) often goes to the students picked early as “capable”, even though readiness shifts from topic to topic. Checking that understanding has stuck (Aether) varies from class to class. And one teacher can’t run five levels at once, so a child whose core learning level is above or below their year level gets less of what they need.
This kind of help
Tutoring alongside school
What this means for your child
None of these is the wrong choice. Each one does its own band well. Trouble starts when a child needs a band that the help they are getting skips.
- A child who does lots of practice tests but keeps losing marks on the same kind of question usually has a gap at Earth, not a shortage of Air.
- A child who flies through worksheets but freezes on a worded problem often needs Water and Air: someone to teach the idea, then connect it.
- A child who understood it in the lesson but can’t do it a week later needs Aether: a check that the rung is secure before moving on.
Four questions to ask any kind of help
- Where does it start: at my child’s core learning level, or at their year level?
- Who teaches the new idea, and how?
- How does it check that learning has stuck before moving on?
- What happens at home between sessions?
The Which band is it? series
Find your child’s core learning level
Our free assessment takes about 1 hour and finds your child’s core learning level in English and Maths, topic by topic. You receive a free report and a consultation to talk it through, with no obligation.